Showing posts with label Mussie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mussie. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

Update From CHSFS about Mussie Closure

In mid-July, we shared that one of our partners, Mussie Orphanage, had its license to operate orphanages revoked by the Ethiopian Charities and Societies Administration (CSA). Although we continue to have more questions than answers, we would like to share what we have learned in the past several weeks:

  • The license revocation continues to be:
    • attributed to organizational leadership and community development shortcomings and does not indicate a problem with child care or adoption processing
    • an issue separate from and unrelated to CHSFS
    • unrelated to the manner in which children came into care
  • CHSFS continues to be reassured by government officials that
    • our adoption work in Ethiopia is not under scrutiny
    • our practices are revered as best practices by agencies and governments in numerous countries, including the USA and Ethiopia
  • Mussie Orphanage is
    • cooperating with the authorities; the director was detained for questioning for a period of time (which is not uncommon in Ethiopia) and released without charges being filed
    • appealing the revocation of its license at the regional and federal level
    • advocating for the best interest of the children who had previously been in their care
    • maintaining its administrative functions which include processing post-placement reports and post-placement service requests
  • CHSFS staff in Ethiopia:
    • have had many conversations with Ethiopian officials about the cases of families affected by the closure
    • have communicated with government officials almost daily regarding adoption cases that were already in-process at the time of the orphanage closure
  • MOWA in Awassa:
    • is still in the initial stages of investigating the possibility for children who were referred for international adoption to be permanently reconnected with their birth family and receive financial assistance from the government to ensure their basic needs are met
    • has not yet reunited any children with their birth families
  • Families who had been referred a child through Mussie Orphanage prior to the closure are making difficult personal decisions about how they would like to proceed--continue pursuing the adoption of the child referred to them through Mussie, pursue the referral of another child, or end their pursuit of an adoption from Ethiopia

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

More Information From Holt


The individual who is still being held from the Mussie orphanages works only at the Hosana site and is not involved with the orphanages that Holt works with at all since they do not use that site. They were NOT saying that anything illicit was happening, but they were pretty clear that they are not involved with that location.

They do not believe that anything illegal/unethical was happening at their Mussie sites.

They said that all the paperwork that they have checked from Mussie has always been correct and corroborates with their own investigations.

They have temporarily halted birth family meetings as these were facilitated by Mussie staff. They are trying to get these back as soon as possible. Holt is reconsidering many options including allowing families to video tape the meetings and even video taping parts of the intake process. P
revious/current/potential Holt families are encouraged to email them as well telling them how important it is to let this happen.

Tuesday, July 19, 2011

Holt Letters to Clients Regarding Mussie Closure.

July 5

Over the course of the last several months Holt’s adoptive families have been incredibly patient and understanding as various rumors in Ethiopia have been sorted out, and worked through. We thank you for your understanding of the recent challenges and the changes.

Holt Ethiopia has informed us that Holt’s partner Mussie Child Care Center has had its license to operate revoked by the government of Ethiopia. As we understand it at this time, the reason for this revocation is that Mussie works primarily in adoption, not doing enough other humanitarian work. The revocation had nothing to do with the quality of child care provided and we understand that there have been no allegations of misconduct on the part of Mussie staff.

As a reminder, the legal framework in Ethiopia does not permit Holt to operate a child care center therefore requiring partnerships with local organizations that provide child care. Mussie is a large organization that works with a variety of partners. Holt partners with Mussie in the area of intercountry adoption and we have placed significant numbers of children from this organization’s orphanages in the last couple of years. Even though Mussie does provide other humanitarian work, some officials feel it is inadequate relative to the efforts they do in the area of intercountry adoption. As you are likely aware Holt International has a large family preservation project in Southern Ethiopia and is supporting the building of a hospital in Shinshicho. These projects are not carried out by Mussie, but are directly implemented by Holt International in Ethiopia.

Like you, our immediate concern is for your children and how this will impact the completion of your adoption process. Children who were in Mussie’s Durame orphanage and matched with a Holt family have been transferred to orphanages Holt partners with in the capital of Addis Ababa. Children who were in Mussie’s Wolayita orphanage have been transferred to another licensed child care center in Wolayita. We are still awaiting specific details regarding this new location.

As this announcement has just been made there are many unanswered questions. We will continue to update you as we receive more detailed information from our Ethiopia staff.

{*Please note that Mussie is only one of the orphanages that Holt partners with. If your child is referred originally through Help for the Needy (Halaba, Negeste Axum), or Mission of Charity orphanage this notification is not relevant to your case.}

This is what we know so far:

Adoption Processing: It is unclear at this point what the revocation means for adoption processing. Holt Ethiopia staff will be meeting with the Ethiopian authorities over the next several days to clarify the situation. At this point, however the Ethiopian authorities have stated support in working with Holt to complete adoption cases for children in Mussie’s care. We expect naturally that cases that are further along (have a Federal court decision or assigned court date) will be the least impacted. But again, we will not know for sure until the meetings have been completed with the Ethiopian authorities.

Birth Parent Meetings: During this time Holt will no longer be able to offer birth parent meetings. These meetings were arranged by Mussie and Holt is not able to facilitate these meetings independently.

Child Releases: As mentioned above Holt also partners with Negeste Axum in the North of Ethiopia, and with Help for the Needy Association in Halaba. We believe that this announcement will have no effect on children released to us from these two orphanages.

Holt regrets that this announcement may cause additional stress and anxiety for your family. We realize that you may have questions and concerns, and we are happy to speak with you anytime. Please do not hesitate to call us or email us. Families who are directly impacted by this announcement have been contacted and we will continue to keep everyone up to date as any additional information becomes available.

Warmly,

Africa Programs Staff

Holt International Children’s Services



July 8

We know that the news of the Mussie Orphanage License revocation has been upsetting, and for that we are truly sorry. Actions within Ethiopia were taken quickly and were outside of normal protocols and procedures for closing an orphanage. We are still working through what this will mean for the children and our families. We apologize that his update is coming out so late on a Friday. We have literally been on the phone all day, and we hope that the information contained here is somewhat reassuring.

This is what we know so far:

Adoption Processing: It is unclear at this point what the revocation means for adoption processing. Holt Ethiopia staff will be meeting with the Ethiopian authorities over the next several days to clarify the situation. At this point, however the Ethiopian authorities have stated support in working with Holt to complete adoption cases for children in Mussie’s care. We expect naturally that cases that are further along (have a Federal court decision or assigned court date) will be the least impacted. But again, we will not know for sure until the meetings have been completed with the Ethiopian authorities.

Birth Parent Meetings: During this time Holt will no longer be able to offer birth parent meetings. These meetings were arranged by Mussie and Holt is not able to facilitate these meetings independently.

Child Releases: As mentioned above Holt also partners with Negeste Axum in the North of Ethiopia, and with Help for the Needy Association in Halaba. We believe that this announcement will have no effect on children released to us from these two orphanages.

Holt regrets that this announcement may cause additional stress and anxiety for your family. We realize that you may have questions and concerns, and we are happy to speak with you anytime. Please do not hesitate to call us or email us. Families who are directly impacted by this announcement have been contacted and we will continue to keep everyone up to date as any additional information becomes available.

Warmly,

Africa Programs Staff

Holt International Children’s Services


July 15

We know that the news regarding Mussie’s closure has been disconcerting and we are sorry about this. This week, there have been some positive developments:

Good News:

Last week we were asked to cancel the court dates for three families who were about to travel as the courts were not certain they would be able to hear their cases. Since then, these families have been assigned a new court date and will travel soon! It was not necessary to cancel any additional trips to
Ethiopia.
At this time children who are in Addis without a court decree have not been moved. We are not sure if this means that they will not be moved in the future, but it seems to be a good sign. There has been no additional talk of returning these children to Durame.
Appropriate paperwork has been filed so that children who were transferred to Kingdom Vision International in Wolayita can be moved. Our Country Representative, Dr. Fikru, is in the South currently working with authorities on transferring these children.

WHAT WE KNOW

Rumors about Mussie staff being arrested or imprisoned are false. No orphanage staff has been charged with any wrong doing. An investigation is underway and Mussie staff has been interviewed and are fully cooperative. At this time we understand informally from various sources that no evidence of unethical conduct or illegal activities have surfaced from this investigation. We have spoken with other adoption agencies who are affected by the Mussie closure and they report the same information.
Rumors that Mussie was operating without a valid license to do so are false. Mussie’s license was valid up to the moment of the forced closure
The rash actions taken in this rapid closure, including transferring the children in Mussie Wolayta to another Wolaiyta orphanage were not conducted within the context of Ethiopian law. Action was taken despite a lack of evidence of any orphanage misconduct.
It is our understanding that there is no precedent for this rapid type of closure and so this has added to some of the confusion and limits our ability to predict what will happen.
Holt was not aware that this revocation was going to happen and could not have foreseen the way in which this occurred.

INFORMATION ON THE CHILDREN’S LOCATION

Children in Wolaiyta: We have learned from our staff on the ground that children who were in the Mussie Wolaita orphanage are safe, and have been transferred to Kingdom Vision International, another licensed facility in Wolaiyta.

Children who are in Addis, but whose court decree has not yet been issued: There is some discussion that the government may choose to transfer children who are in Addis back down to Durame if a court decree has not yet been issued for their case. This is something that may or may not happen. Our staff on the ground is strenuously advocating and legally petitioning for the children to remain in Addis, since it is clearly in the children’s best interest. We will update families as we have information about transfer of children from one orphanage to another. Please note that the original transfer of children from Durame to Addis was done in a perfectly legal and proper fashion.

Who has “Legal Guardianship”? Legal guardianship of children who were originally in a Mussie-run orphanage remains with Mussie. At this time discussions are underway to determine to which agency the legal guardianship shall be transferred. We do not yet know what delays may be associated with this or when this may be resolved.

CASE PROCESSING

First and foremost we would like to share that our staff on the ground is optimistic that all cases will continue to be processed through to completion. There may however, be some delays associated with the closure of Mussie as a determination is made regarding who shall be granted guardianship of children who were in Mussie’s care.

Children who are already home: Please be assured that there is no reason whatsoever to think that the information in your child reports is inaccurate or incorrect. This closure is not a result of any unethical conduct, wrong doing, or shoddy work on the part of Mussie staff.

Cases with Court Decrees Waiting for Embassy Submission
We understand that your cases will continue to be processed as usual. If your child is currently still in Wolaiyta we anticipate that they will be transferred to one of the care centers we work with in Addis at some point. Time frame in which this will occur is not yet known to us.

Cases which have been heard by the Court but do not yet have a Court Decree
If your case has been heard in court but a court decree has not yet been issued, your case will continue to be processed as normal. Ministry letters will continue to be issued for these cases. However, it is possible that there may be some delay.

Cases that have Court Dates but have not yet traveled
Unfortunately, Holt had to ask families with court cases scheduled for next week to cancel their trip. We were very upset to have to do this and know that this was very hard on these families. The courts were unable to confirm that they could receive our families and we were not able to guarantee that these families would have been able to see their children. We do not yet know if the next group of families will be asked to postpone their travels as well, and anxiously await additional information from our staff on the ground. Please keep these families in your thoughts and prayers.

We are happy to answer any additional questions that you may have about your adoption. Due to a high volume of call/emails we apologize that we are not able to respond to your inquiries as quickly as we would like. We will, however, respond to your inquiry as quickly as we can and will continue to send email updates as concrete information becomes available.
Warmly,
Africa Programs Staff
Holt International



Many families have expressed concern and frustration over this recent orphanage closure and how it might affect their adoption process in general. Ethiopia and the US Embassy have implemented many changes in just the last year which have contributed to some of the unknowns and delays that we have experienced. Following are some observations regarding Ministry Letters and new releases.

Ministry Letters: Ministry letters required for the issuance of the court decree have been delayed lately. This is something that has historically been the case. Prior to adoptive families traveling to Ethiopia, court cases would be re-scheduled often 3-4 times because these letters were not available. Now that families have to appear in court, the letters are still often delayed, but the court date has remained the same.

Please remember: a delay in the issuance of the Ministry letter does not mean that something is wrong with your adoption case, rather it is reflective of the challenges the Ministry faces as they process a high volume of adoption cases with limited resources. Unfortunately, Ministry letters are not issued in chronological order of your court dates. This means some families may jump ahead of others. While it is regrettable, it is not something that is in Holt’s control.

We have heard rumors that arrangements have been underway to provide additional resources to the Ministry to help with case processing. If/when we hear more details, we will share them with you.

Releases: Many families have inquired about current wait times and what Mussie’s closure means for the wait for a referral. Holt has two additional partners that we work with in Ethiopia, and we expect more partnerships to be formed in the near future. Since these are new partnerships, we are still learning what the pace of releases will be over all.

Wait for Referral: Currently, the estimated wait time is 9-12 months for a referral. As of now, families who have waited the longest have been waiting 9 months.

We are happy to answer any questions you may have!
Warmly,
Africa Programs Staff
Holt International Children’s Services




CHSFS Letter to Clients Regarding Mussie Closure

July 5: Dear Families,
CHSFS Ethiopia has informed us that Mussie Child Care Center in Hosana has had its license to operate revoked by the government of Ethiopia. We were told that the reason for this revocation is related to leadership issues and community development work, and does not reflect on child care or adoption processing. CHSFS is currently calling the families that will be impacted by this news.

While the news is troubling, it involves a very small group of CHSFS child referrals. It does not affect the adoption process for families with children at other orphanages.

Our primary concern is for the children and how this will impact the completion of your adoption process. We have learned that children whose court decisions have been made have been moved to Addis. For cases where no court decision has been made, Ethiopian authorities have moved children to an orphanage in Wolayta. CHSFS staff in Ethiopia have gone to the orphanage in Wolayta and report that it is a fine facility.

CHSFS Ethiopia staff have contacted MOWA and regional authorities to advocate for smooth processing of these cases. We now must wait for the Ethiopian government to make a decision. We have staff monitoring the situation closely on your behalf. We regret that this announcement may cause additional stress and anxiety for your family. We will follow-up as soon as we have additional information. Please contact your CHSFS program specialist or social worker directly if you have further questions.

Sincerly,
The Ethiopia Team


July 15, 2011

Dear Families,

At the beginning of July, 2011, one of our partners, Mussie Orphanage, had its license to operate revoked by the Ethiopian Charities and Societies Administration (CSA), the government office which oversees all Non-Governmental Organizations (NGO) including adoption service providers and orphanages. The revocation is being blamed on organizational leadership and community development shortcomings and does not indicate a problem with child care or adoption processing. In speaking to government officials, Children's Home has been assured this licensing issue that is separate and unrelated to CHSFS.

As parents who have adopted from Ethiopia and in particular through Mussie Orphanage, we recognize that this information may cause stress, sadness or fear. We have more questions than answers at this time, as well, so we feel similar stress and concern. At the same time we want you to know that we have been assured on numerous occasions that our adoption work in Ethiopia is not under scrutiny, and we believe that our practices are revered as best practices by agencies and governments in numerous countries, including the USA and ET. The focus of this case does not seem to be related to the manner in which children came into care. We continue to push for information and disclosure, and we will share reliable information as soon as it is known.

Mussie Orphanage is reported to be acting in cooperation with authorities, but is appealing the revocation of its license at the regional and federal level, as well. It will likely take some time before an outcome of the appeal is known, and so the long-term implications for post placement reports and post placement services is uncertain. However, at this time, Mussie Orphanage is maintaining its administrative functions which include processing post-placement reports and post-placement service requests. We take our obligations to birth families seriously. In the short-term, if Mussie Orphanage becomes unable to process post-placement reports and service requests, we will make use of our established relationships with social workers in the area to ensure that we fulfill our obligations. We will create a longer-term solution when and if that becomes needed.

For the next couple of weeks, we will be focusing our advocacy and outreach toward the in process children and families in Ethiopia. But we will stay on top of this developing news and keep placed families informed with updates and impacts in a timely manner. If you have a service request at this time, we ask that you contact our Ethiopia post adoption services area.

Sincerely,

Kjersti Olson
Director of International Programs

Mussie Orphanages

Locations: Hossana, Wolayita and Durame
Agencies Partnered with these orphanages: CHSFS, Holt and Bethany
Families who used both BFAS and Hope have reported that their paperwork was signed off by Mussie as well.

Children in the three Mussie orphanages were moves to Kingdom Vision International in Wolayita. CHSFS reported that after an initial visit with the children, Mussie staff was no longer involved with their care.

The orphanage director and another staff member of the Hosanna center were arrested. Last news was that the director is still under arrest.